Products

Dreamy cotton candy in a bottle! Supernatural’s Cotton Candy Clouds captures the sweet, nostalgic taste of classic cotton candy in a convenient dropper bottle. Add just a drop or two to frostings, glazes, cakes, and more for dreamy flavor without adding any color —...

Add a drop of gummy goodness. Supernatural’s Gummy Bear delivers the nostalgic, fruity taste of freshly opened gummy bears in a convenient dropper bottle. Just a drop adds juicy gummy bear-inspired flavor (think cherry and fruit punch!) to frostings, glazes, cakes, and more —...

Spooky orange, naturally made sprinkles. These soft, naturally colored orange sprinkles bring the perfect pop of spooky-season fun to Halloween baking. Without any artificial dyes, they’re an easy way to decorate cookies, cupcakes, and festive cakes with warm, autumn-inspired color. Whether you’re making trick-or-treat...

Soft pink, naturally made sprinkles. These soft, naturally colored pink sprinkles bring a cheerful, whimsical touch to baking year-round. While perfect for birthdays, showers, and Valentine’s treats, they’re just as lovely for holiday baking when you want a pop of color on snow-white cupcakes,...

Naturally beautiful food coloring. This plant-based, vegan food coloring set comes in four beautifully bright colors: Red, Yellow, Orange, and Blue, though they can all be mixed to create a rainbow of beautiful hues. Bakers love this all-natural food coloring because the food colors...

Colorful crunch, no artificial stuff! Add a naturally colorful crunch to your baked goods with these dye-free rainbow nonpareils. Made with plant-based colors and free from artificial dyes, soy, and gluten, they’re perfect for decorating cupcakes, cookies, cakes — or making your own nonpareil...

Rainbow sprinkles made with zero artificial ingredients. Bring on the fun (and the color!) These soft, sweet sprinkles are like instant joy for cookies, cupcakes, and ice cream. Made with plant-based colors from veggies, spices, and even algae, they skip the artificial stuff but...

Festive red, naturally made sprinkles. These soft, naturally colored red sprinkles bring a joyful pop of color to holiday baking—without any artificial dyes. Their bright, festive hue is perfect for Christmas cookies, winter cupcakes, and celebration cakes that call for a little extra cheer....

Add a dreamy touch of vanilla. Supernatural’s Vanilla Dream Machine delivers rich, classic vanilla flavor in a convenient dropper bottle. Just a drop or two enhances frostings, glazes, cakes, and more with smooth, dreamy vanilla — an easy way to bring warmth and sweetness...

Bites of delightfully crunchy sweetness. Give your baked goods a beautiful (and sweet!) finishing touch with a sprinkle of these small crunchy sugar chunks. Made of compressed sugar crystals, they are ideal for baking as they will not dissolve into your baked goods. Try...

Sweet, salty, and so much fun! Now a New York Times Bestseller! Packed with nearly 100 recipes, Sweet & Salty! is a hands-on baking book that teaches kids both the “how” and “why” of baking through treats they’ll be excited to make. From a...

The sweet spice that does it all! With notes of cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg, this single-origin Sweet Allspice adds cozy depth to baked goods — from spiced cookies and quick breads to holiday pies and cakes. Grown on a biodynamic farm in Guatemala and...

Scoop the perfect bite with our Tablespoon Scoop! The Tablespoon Scoop is your go-to tool for perfectly portioned dough and batter every time. Whether you're making drop cookies, mini scones, pancakes, muffins, or biscuits, this scoop ensures consistent size for even baking. The quick...

A time-saving pan! Cut about 25% off the time needed to bake a typical 1-hour quick bread with this longer, slimmer pan. We love how this pan creates smaller slices than a traditional full-sized loaf, perfect for an afternoon snack. Stoneware retains heat to...

Scoop the perfect bite with our Teaspoon Scoop! The Teaspoon Scoop is the perfect tool for consistent, even baking. Designed to easily portion out dough and batter, it ensures your mini drop cookies, scones, and pizzelle are perfectly sized every time. With a quick...

We just couldn't say goodbye. When our favorite terry pot holder was discontinued, we went to work to recreate it. Preserving features our customers loved, and sprinkling in a few more, we proudly reveal our new Terry Pot Holder! Made of soft terry cloth...

A complete starter kit for pizza night! The Book of Pizza Starter Set brings together everything you need for an easy, fun pizza-making night. Along with The Book of Pizza: Recipes for Every Pizza Maker, you’ll get a 12" Baker’s Peel for smooth launches...

The ultimate cookie cook book from America’s most trusted baking resource. Revised and updated with step-by-step instructions, detailed illustrations, and fresh new recipes, this new edition of The Essential Cookie Companion will inspire you to bake your most impressive and incredible-tasting cookies, no matter...

The one and only Thermapen® ONE. A food thermometer is one of the most valuable tools in the kitchen, whether you're baking bread, cooking meat, or making candy. Having one that's lightning fast and pinpoint accurate is another story - that's where the Thermapen®...

Make charming thumbprint cookies with elegantly embossed designs! Our custom-made cutter set features four classic shapes – Heart, Square, Circle, and Star – to elevate the look of your typical thumbprint cookies. Simply spray cutter lightly, press down plunger and achieve beautifully embossed dough...